The midnight toast is the one moment of the year when almost everyone in the room is holding the same drink. If you’re not drinking, that used to mean sparkling cider or a glass of water. Non-alcoholic sparkling wine has improved enough that you can now pour something that looks, pops, and tastes like the real thing.
Sparkling is also the easiest style of wine to make without alcohol. Still wines lean on alcohol for body, and they taste thin without it. Bubbles fill that gap. A dry non-alcoholic sparkling wine gets closer to the original than any red or white does.
I tasted the bottles below chilled, in flutes, on their own and next to each other. Here’s how they rank for a New Year’s Eve toast.
The quick verdict: Noughty Sparkling Chardonnay is the best all-round bottle. French Bloom Le Blanc is the one to buy when you’d normally splurge on champagne. Fre Sparkling Brut is the sensible pick for a crowd. TÖST is the answer for guests who want nothing that started life as wine.
How I judged them
Dryness came first, because most non-alcoholic sparkling wines are sweeter than brut champagne and a sweet toast gets tiring after two sips. Then the bubbles: how fine they are and how long they last in the glass. Then the bottle itself, since a cork and a pop are part of the ritual at midnight. Last, whether the wine is 0.0% or under 0.5% ABV, which matters to anyone who is pregnant, in recovery, or avoiding alcohol entirely.
#1 Noughty Sparkling Chardonnay
Best Overall
Why it’s #1: Noughty is the driest bottle here and the one that tastes most like sparkling wine. It’s made from organic chardonnay with the alcohol removed, and it keeps a crisp green apple character with a clean finish. It has about half the sugar of French Bloom, which is why it doesn’t read as grape soda. The cork comes out with a real pop.
- Bottle: 750ml, cork and cage
- ABV: 0.0%
- Sugar: About 2.9g per 100ml
- Profile: Dry, green apple, light citrus
Pros: Driest in the lineup, organic and vegan, true 0.0% Cons: Lighter body than champagne, bubbles fade faster than the real thing Best for: The midnight toast, and anyone who usually drinks brut
Shop Noughty Sparkling Chardonnay on Amazon
#2 French Bloom Le Blanc
Best Splurge
Why it’s #2: French Bloom is what you buy when the bottle needs to feel like an occasion. It’s made in France from organic chardonnay, dealcoholized and blended with a little organic grape juice and lemon. It has more body and a rounder, more floral flavor than Noughty, with pear and white flowers up front. It’s also a little sweeter, which keeps it out of first place for brut drinkers. The bottle looks the part on a table.
- Bottle: 750ml, cork and cage
- ABV: 0.0%
- Sugar: About 5.9g per 100ml, none added
- Profile: Pear, white flowers, lemon, soft finish
Pros: Most body and complexity, organic, true 0.0%, beautiful bottle Cons: The most expensive pick here, sweeter than Noughty Best for: Gifts, small dinners, anyone who’d normally open vintage champagne
#3 Fre Sparkling Brut
Best for a Crowd
Why it’s #3: Fre is the non-alcoholic sparkling wine you can find in almost any US grocery store, and in stores it’s usually the cheapest corked bottle on this list. Sutter Home has been making it for decades. It’s fruitier and softer than the first two, with apple and a touch of peach, and the bubbles are a little coarse. Nobody will mistake it for champagne, but it’s pleasant, it pops, and you can buy six bottles without wincing.
- Bottle: 750ml, cork and cage
- ABV: Under 0.5%
- Profile: Apple, peach, off-dry
Pros: Cheap, easy to find, reliable Cons: Sweeter than its “brut” label suggests, not true 0.0% Best for: Big parties, mimosas, sparkling cocktails
Shop Fre Sparkling Brut on Amazon
#4 Surely Sparkling Rosé
Best Rosé
Why it’s #4: If your table prefers pink, Surely is the bottle. It’s an alcohol-removed California rosé with strawberry and citrus notes and a dry finish. It photographs well, which counts for something on New Year’s Eve. It ranks fourth because rosé is a narrower crowd-pleaser than a white brut, and it costs more than Fre.
- Bottle: 750ml
- ABV: Under 0.5%
- Profile: Strawberry, citrus, dry
Pros: Dry for a rosé, pretty in the glass Cons: Pricey, not true 0.0% Best for: Rosé drinkers, a second option beside a white
Shop Surely Sparkling Rosé on Amazon
#5 Lyre’s Classico
Best in a Can
Why it’s #5: Lyre’s Classico is a prosecco-style sparkling sold in single-serve 250ml cans. There’s no cork and no pop, which costs it points at midnight. What you get in return is zero waste. One can is one generous glass, so the lone non-drinker at a party isn’t left with most of an open bottle going flat. Lyre’s labels it under 0.5% ABV.
- Pack: 4 cans, 250ml each
- ABV: Under 0.5%
- Profile: Dry, lightly fruity, prosecco style
Pros: Single serve, easy to carry to someone else’s party Cons: No cork, loses fizz quickly once poured Best for: Bringing your own to a party, solo toasts
Shop Lyre’s Classico on Amazon
#6 TÖST
Best Non-Wine Option
Why it’s #6: TÖST isn’t wine. It’s a dry sparkling drink made from white tea, white cranberry, and ginger, and it has never been fermented. That makes it the safest pour for guests who avoid anything dealcoholized. It doesn’t taste like champagne. It tastes like a crisp, lightly gingery sparkling tea, served from a bottle that looks like champagne. Judged as its own drink, it’s very good.
- Bottle: 750ml
- ABV: 0.0%, never fermented
- Profile: White tea, cranberry, ginger
Pros: No dealcoholized wine at all, dry, refreshing Cons: Doesn’t taste like wine Best for: Guests in recovery, pregnant guests, kids’ table upgrades
Quick winners guide
| Pick | Best for | True 0.0%? |
|---|---|---|
| Noughty Sparkling Chardonnay | Best overall, driest | Yes |
| French Bloom Le Blanc | Splurge and gifts | Yes |
| Fre Sparkling Brut | Crowds and cocktails | No |
| Surely Sparkling Rosé | Rosé drinkers | No |
| Lyre’s Classico | Single servings | No |
| TÖST | No wine at all | Yes |
How much to buy and how to serve it
A 750ml bottle pours about six toast-sized glasses. For the midnight toast alone, one bottle covers six guests. If it’s the main drink of the night, plan on half a bottle each.
Serve it colder than you would champagne. Without alcohol, any sweetness shows more as the wine warms up, so give the bottles at least three hours in the fridge or 30 minutes in an ice bucket. Open them just before midnight. Non-alcoholic sparkling loses its bubbles faster than the real thing, and a bottle opened at ten will be flat by twelve.
What to make with the rest of the bottle
Leftover bubbles are an excuse for cocktails. A French 75 works well with a dry bottle like Noughty, and the cranberry Poinsettia is built for Fre Brut. On New Year’s Day, whatever is left goes into a Mimosa. For still wines, reds, and more sparkling options, see the full best non-alcoholic wines ranking.
This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. How this works.