Wassail is the drink behind the carol. The word comes from an Old English toast, “waes hael,” meaning “be well,” and for centuries English villagers carried a bowl of it door to door in midwinter. Older versions were built on ale or wine. The cider-based wassail most American families make today is alcohol-free by default, which makes it one of the easiest holiday punches to serve to everyone.
This batch fills about ten mugs and makes the whole house smell like December.
How it differs from mulled cider
Citrus is the difference. Mulled cider is apple and spice. Wassail adds orange and lemon juice, which brighten the pot and keep ten cups of cider from tasting heavy. Taste before you sweeten. Fresh cider varies a lot, and some batches need no honey at all.
Whole spices only
Ground spices turn the pot gritty and cloudy. Whole cloves, allspice berries, and cinnamon sticks give a cleaner flavor and strain out easily. Studding the orange slices with the cloves is the traditional method, and it saves you from fishing them out later.
Serving a crowd
Wassail holds well. After the first simmer, move it to a slow cooker on the warm setting and let guests ladle their own. Anyone who wants a stronger-tasting mug can add an ounce of non-alcoholic bourbon from our best bourbon substitutes list. Serve it alongside Mulled Wine for a warm drinks station, with the Spiced Apple Chai Mule as the cold option.