Coquito is Puerto Rico’s Christmas drink, a cold, thick coconut punch that families make by the bottle and hand out to neighbors through December. The name means “little coconut.” It’s often compared to eggnog, but most traditional recipes contain no egg at all, and the flavor is coconut and cinnamon first.
This recipe makes about six cups, enough for twelve small servings. Coquito is rich, so it’s poured into small glasses, about four ounces at a time.
Two kinds of coconut
Cream of coconut and coconut milk are different products, and you need both. Cream of coconut is the sweetened, syrupy one sold near the cocktail mixers. Coconut milk is unsweetened and comes from the international aisle. Swap one for the other and the batch ends up either cloying or thin.
Making it without rum
A virgin coquito with the rum left out tastes fine but one-note. A cup of non-alcoholic dark rum such as Lyre’s Dark Cane brings back the molasses and oak that balance all that sweetness. Our best non-alcoholic rum substitutes page lists other bottles. No rum alternative on hand? Add an extra half teaspoon of vanilla and a tablespoon of strong brewed black tea.
Give it a night
Coquito improves as it sits. The spices bloom and the texture thickens after a night in the fridge. The coconut fat will separate and firm up when cold, which is normal. Let the bottle stand for five minutes, then shake it hard. It keeps for about a week refrigerated. For a warm drink to serve beside it, try Hot Buttered Rum.