Hot buttered rum dates back to colonial America, when rum was cheap and winters were long. It’s a mug of hot water, dark rum, and a spoonful of butter creamed with brown sugar and spice. The butter melts into a thin golden layer on top, and the whole thing tastes like the inside of a cinnamon roll.
The spiced butter
The butter mixture, usually called the batter, is the heart of the drink. Soften the butter first so it blends with the sugar instead of clumping. The pinch of salt is not optional. It keeps the drink from tasting flat and sweet, which is a bigger risk without alcohol to cut the richness.
The batter keeps in the fridge for two weeks, so it’s worth making a larger batch. Multiply everything by eight, roll it into a log in parchment, and slice off a tablespoon whenever you want a mug.
Choosing the rum
You need a dark, molasses-forward bottle here. Lyre’s Dark Cane has the caramel and spice notes to stand up to the butter. A white rum alternative disappears. Our best non-alcoholic rum substitutes page compares the other dark options.
Water temperature
Use water just off the boil. Cooler water leaves the butter in greasy beads instead of a smooth layer. For a richer version, replace half the water with hot apple cider. If you like this, the Spiced Eggnog Mocktail and Coquito use the same bottle.